Showing posts with label Supply and Demand. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Supply and Demand. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 29, 2026

About the housing affordability problem.......

 

............................there are two main culprits.   The first is the huge swath of the local building companies that could not survive the Great Recession.  Since we decided several decades ago that every high school graduate needed to go to college, there was no back filling in the building trades.  No local builders building equals a shortage of supply.   The second is the following chart.  Don't let anyone tell you differently, very low interest rates are inflationary for the single-family housing markets.  Since buyers tend to pay based on their monthly payment, low interest rates enable buyers to borrow more, thus pay more, which is a great boon to sellers.   Very low interest rates combined with limited supply quickly allowed the sharp increase in home values.  Voila—an affordability "crisis".









chart courtesy of this post


A few more years of this.........................

 

.................and the supply/demand scales will level out.  Then, and only then, can we talk seriously about solving the affordability problem.   Historically, one million housing starts per year is the magic number. 


Tuesday, December 2, 2025

Ben Carlson.......................


...........takes a look at the housing affordability crisis:

It won’t make you feel any better as a young person in the U.S. to know that it’s even harder for people to afford homes in other countries around the globe.

But these numbers help put things into perspective that things can always get worse.

If the government doesn’t make this a priority the housing affordability crisis likely will get worse in the coming years.

Editor's Note:   The only thing the government can do to relieve the housing affordability crisis is to remove many of the regulatory barriers to new development.  At the end of the day, supply versus demand still rules.  If it were easier to build new housing, more housing would be built.  Once supply exceeds demand, or even matches it, prices will moderate.  Any attempt to subsidize home buyers or tenants, will only cause prices to keep increasing.  Trust me on this.


Friday, May 2, 2025

Got it half right............................


 I would love to see a situation where politicians make housing their entire platform. Tear up all of the red tape. Incentive homebuilders to build more homes. Offer first-time homebuyers low mortgage rates they missed out on.

-Ben Carlson, from this post


The affordability problems in our current housing market is being caused by that pesky law of supply and demand.  The supply has been constrained for the past thirteen years for multiple reasons.*  Demand was unleashed seven or eight years ago by absurdly low interest rates and by a generation that ignored the experts that said they would be "urbanized."  Left to their own devices, our kids said "screw the big cities, we want a single-family house with a two-car garage and a yard."  When overheated demand meets constrained supply, you get doubling of prices in a very short time frame—and an affordability problem.  Slowly but surely, supply is picking up—but it will likely take another five years before the supply actually meets the demand.  Be very careful of offering subsidies to buyers in a market like this.  Those subsidies will just end up in the pockets of sellers.  Stoking demand in a tight housing market is a recipe for higher home prices.

If you want to solve the affordability problem, subsidize homebuilders and developers.  They will then do what they always do when incentivized—over build.  Then, and only then, will affordability stand a chance.


*The supply of housing has been constrained by a combination of factors that include, but is not limited to, the following:

    1.  The Great Recession of 2008ish was caused in part by super-heated housing construction.   After the dot.com bubble burst, the construction industry became a major engine for keeping the economy perky.  By 2003 more homes were being built than could be sold to traditional home buyers.  Not wanting to stop the gravy train, politicians decided we should sell those new homes to buyers who could not afford them.  This was cleverly done by fiddling with the requirements for securing a mortgage.  2004-05 was the wild west of mortgage lending.  All you needed to get a loan was to be able to fog a mirror.

    2.   The Great Recession caused multiple defaults on those non-traditional mortgages.  All of a sudden there was a massive supply of available homes and no demand.  Naturally, prices fell.  Homebuilders could not compete with prices of this surplus inventory, so they did the sensible thing and left the industry.

    3.  About the same time all this was going on, our society decided that everyone needed a four-year liberal arts college experience.  We suffered a collective amnesia about the importance of training the next generation of plumbers, electricians, HVAC technicians, carpenters, roofers, etc.

    4.   In 2003 there were probably 15 home building companies in our community (of about 80,000 folks).  By 2013 there were only three remaining.   

    5.   Guess what happens when there are only a handful of tradespeople in a market that needs a bushelful?   Those trades people, for the first time in memory, had pricing power.  All of a sudden, construction labor prices started rising—quickly.

    6.  The onset of Covid led to the snarling of supply lines and the interruption of the production of building materials.  The just-in-time theory of inventory doesn't work very well when there are disruptions.  Those building product suppliers, for the first time in memory, also had pricing power.  Prices for plywood, concrete, drywall, etc. all shot through the roof.

    7.   Increasing governmental regulations (zoning and NIMBY opposition to change, density restrictions, subdivision regulations, green space requirements, turn lanes and deacceleration lanes, impact fees, sewer/water tap fees, and a myriad of other useful improvements) confronting developers of subdivisions has made the development process more expensive and more time consuming—a tough combination which impacts affordability,

    8.   We should not forget that residential real estate markets are local in nature, and while your results may vary, the affordability problem is a supple and demand problem, and it will  take time to resolve.


Tuesday, August 20, 2024

Thursday, June 20, 2024

The tough housing market...............

 

No matter how you slice it, the home building sector seems strangely slow given our population growth . . .

Brian Wesbury offers a pretty good take on why the housing market is so tight.  He includes governmental hurdles as a major problem.  Maybe.  We think the major problem (that he fails to mention) is the wipe out of the small homebuilder - the company that would build 10-12 houses per year - after the 2008 meltdown.  Those guys never recovered and/or aged out, and have not yet been replaced.  We were so focused on sending all high school graduates to college, we forgot the importance of the building trades.  There is still a screaming need for plumbers, electricians, carpenters, drywallers, etc.  The earning potential for those high school graduates entering those trades now seems significantly higher than college graduates with BA degrees.  Just saying.  As an honorable mention for housing problems, we should not forget the serious inflation of building material costs that the covid/broken-supply-chain-years brought us.  Prices have moderated a bit, but not much.  All in all, no quick fix to the housing problem is on the horizon.


 

Sunday, September 11, 2022

Faithful readers....................

 .............are aware I am a big fan of Ben Carlson and his A Wealth of Common Sense blog.  While that hasn't changed, there is a rather large bone to pick with his recent "How the Fed screwed up the Housing Market" post.  Any discussion about the housing market between 2015 and 2022 that does not focus on the lack of supply of housing options (both single and multi family) will miss the main point.  No matter how hard economists may try to repeal the law of supply and demand, they can't.  The supply/demand imbalance in the housing market has never been greater since the early 1960s.  The Fed can play with interest rates to their hearts' content.  Such actions may help or hinder specific buyers/sellers, but until the supply of new homes catches up with a decade of under-building on a national scale, the culprit behind a screwy housing market will be the shortage of new construction.

Tuesday, September 6, 2022

Supply and demand..............

       The housing market has been unbelievably unbalanced over the past two years.  Probably has not been this difficult to buy a new home since three million GIs came home from World War II, got married, and started a baby boom.  If you don't build very many new houses for a dozen years, and a generation coming of age finally decides they want a home, well, at that point no supply meets excess demand.  Anyone trying to buy a house in the past two years is painfully familiar with the story: very few choices, inflated prices, multiple competing offers, sale prices well over list price.  To call this housing market chaotic might be charitable.  Rising interest rates may have started a cooling trend.  Buyers needing mortgages suddenly can't afford to pay as much as they could have six months ago.  Will sanity (from the viewpoint of those of us who prefer calmer markets) return?  Tough to say.  There is still a significant lack of supply to meet any kind of demand.

      Michael Batnick, a fairly bright finance guy, takes a stab at understanding what is going with this blog post.   Love his conclusion:

Eventually the market will find an equilibrium, but right now the housing market is drunk and needs time to sober up.

Thursday, June 9, 2022

expectations.............................

      But this breathtaking increase in the money supply did not, at least immediately, set off inflation.  For while inflation is a monetary phenomenon, it is also a psychological one: when the expectation of inflation becomes widespread, it becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy.

     That prophecy was fulfilled in 2021.  With the Biden administration continuing pandemic relief, which discouraged many for seeking work, and restricting oil and gas production, inflation set in.   Supply chain issues also contributed.

     By December 2021, consumer prices were up seven percent on an annual basis, the highest in 40 years, while producer prices were up 9.6 percent, the highest since that statistic has been compiled.  And the expectation of further inflation is now deeply embedded in the economy.

     Regardless of this, the Biden administration is still pushing hard for its "Build Back Better" plan, which would add at least another $5 trillion to the national debt over the next decade.  And President Biden has airily said that "Milton Friedman is no longer in charge."

     But unfortunately for the Biden presidency—and for the American people—Milton Friedman was right.  Create too much money and you get inflation.  We are witnessing the proof of that right now.

-John Steele Gordon, as he concludes this essay

Tuesday, June 7, 2022

fund-raising...............

      War is, by far, the most expensive of all government operations.  And both the Confederate and United States governments faced unprecedented financial stresses in funding the Civil War.  How each of them met the challenge helped determine, in no small way, the outcome of the war.

     Governments have only three ways to fund operations.  They can tax, they can borrow, and they can print.  Both governments did all three, but the particular mix was very different.  The northern states had a much more advanced economy and a well-established financial system in place.  As a result, the U. S. was able to throw much of the cost of the war onto the future.  In 1860, the national debt had stood at $64 million.  By 1866, it was at $2.7 billion, and about five percent of the North's population has invested in federal bonds.  So the North was able to raise two-thirds of its revenues by borrowing. . . .

     The South had to meet fully 50 percent of its revenue by printing money.  State and City governments also printed money.  And because the South lacked good paper mills and state-of-the-art printing facilities, counterfeiting flourished.  Altogether, the South printed about $1.5 billion in that money, three times as much as the North, despite having only twelve percent of the circulating currency before the war and 21 percent of banking assets.

     The result was catastrophic inflation.  Prices rose 700 percent in the South in just the first two years of the war.  As the war continued, the inflationary spiral deepened and the southern economy began to spin out of control.  Living standards fell sharply while hoarding, shortages, and black markets spread, eroding popular support for the war.

-John Steele Gordon, from his essay Inflation in the United States

Monday, June 6, 2022

a special term.................

      Money is just another commodity, no different from petroleum, pork bellies, or pig iron.  So money, like all commodities, can rise and fall in price, depending on supply and demand.  But because money is, by definition, the one commodity that is universally accepted in exchange for every other commodity, we have a special term for a fall in the price of money:  we call it inflation.  As the price of money falls, the price of every other commodity must go up.

     And what causes the price of money to fall?  The answer is very simple: an increase in the supply of money relative to other goods and services.

-John Steele Gordon,  from his essay, Inflation in the United States

Thursday, April 21, 2022

Supply and demand.................

 


















The construction business is trying its hardest to catch up to the demand for housing.  In our market, anyway, most of the existing available building lots are either under contract or have recently sold.  Faithful readers may remember we had a whole passel of wondrous, wooded building lots available - seemed like for years.  Thankfully, over the past twelve months, almost all of them have sold.

charts may be found here

Saturday, May 15, 2021

the basics...................................

 I realized that the basics of business are straightforward.  It's largely about risk.  If you have a big downside and a small upside, run the other way. If you've got a big upside and a small downside, do the deal.  Always make sure you're getting paid for the risk you take, and never risk what you cannot afford to lose,   Keep it simple. . . . Opportunity is very often embedded in the imbalance between supply and demand.

-Sam Zell,  Am I Being Too Subtle:  Straight Talk From A Business Rebel

Tuesday, January 10, 2017

Hey, wait a minute..................


..................................................what about my history degree?

"Based on data he has collected, the iconic tech entrepreneur and Microsoft co-founder said people with three backgrounds will be the most in-demand in the coming years: sciences, engineering and economics."

-as culled from this essay

Of course us old-fashioned folk believe that the ability to think for yourself, the ability to get along well with a wide variety of people, and the possession of more than a bit of self-discipline are way more important than educational backgrounds.

thanks craig


Tuesday, March 8, 2016

The magic of............................


..............................................................Mr. Market.

y
“The economics of the cannabis industry show us that with 
healthy competition in the market, prices drop, quality rises, 
violence diminishes, and peaceful transactions increase. 

Maybe we should just surrender in the "War on Drugs" and 
declare victory.  Back story here.