Thursday, October 22, 2026

Don't often disagree with................

 

...................Ben Carlson, but I don't agree with his take on (ZIRP) zero interest rate policies.   He sites this:

    Chancellor spends much of the book railing against 
    the period of low interest rates that came out of the 
    Great Financial Crisis. He argues that ultra-low 
    interest rates are dangerous because they encourage 
    excessive risk-taking, punish savers, distort the 
    price of time, inflate asset prices, prop up zombie 
    companies and in many ways weaken the economy.

And responds with this:

    What’s strange to me is that ZIRP didn’t really lead 
    to any of those things. Sure, asset prices went higher 
    but that’s mostly because the stock market went 
    through a lost decade in the 2000s and the behemoth 
    tech companies stepped in to save the day by 
    providing actual profits.

My disagreement is this:  Low interest rates in a real estate market of high demand and low supply are extraordinarily inflationary.   In many markets, including ours, single family residential prices about doubled in the five years between 2018 and 2023.  That is not sustainable and the "affordability" crisis in housing is the result.

Nobody asks me, but the perfect interest rate is that rate which allows local financial institutions to pay savers a rate on their savings accounts just a bit over inflation.   If inflation is 3%, savers should get 3.5% on their savings accounts, which means the financial institutions would have to lend money at 6.5-7%.

And don't tell me 7% is a high interest rate.  We started our commercial real estate brokerage in 1982.  Mortgage rates were 15%.   When we started buying investment properties in 1983, rates were above 13%.   For half our career, we would have killed for a 7% rate.

I feel like an old man yelling at the kids to get off my lawn.


No comments:

Post a Comment